Menu of Cafe Plaza in Columbus, New Mexico, USA

Menu Overview

Cafe Plaza in Columbus, NM, offers an authentic slice of Mexican cuisine that feels both inviting and genuine. Nestled at 54 E Broadway Ave, this family-run restaurant impresses not only with its warm, welcoming atmosphere but also with a menu that balances classic flavors and comfort food staples.

The highlight of their menu is undoubtedly the line-up of hamburgers—something you might not expect in a Mexican restaurant. The Green Chilli Burger, priced at $12.99, stands out with its spicy kick, perfectly capturing the essence of New Mexico’s prized green chilies. Meanwhile, the Popper Burger ($14.99), loaded with spicy poppers and melted cheese, offers a bold, satisfying bite. Both burgers are skillfully crafted, blending American heartiness with Mexican flair.

Beyond burgers, Cafe Plaza excels in offering traditional sides that complement every meal. The Guacamole ($3.00) is fresh and creamy—an ideal starter or accompaniment. Simple yet essential, the Rice and Beans ($2.00 each) deliver classic, well-executed Mexican staples that grounds the meal. Snacks like the Crunchy Taco and Roll Taco at $1.50 each are modest in price but big in flavor, perfect for a light bite or to complete a larger feast.

Not to be overlooked, the breakfast offerings are worth special mention. Customers rave about their breakfast burritos, which come packed with savory fillings and homemade salsas that elevate every bite. The praise from regulars about the chilaquiles highlights the kitchen’s dedication to traditional recipes enriched with homemade sauces, creating a dish that’s vibrant and full of depth. Paired with a simple cup of coffee or a refreshing chocolate milk, breakfast here feels comforting and deeply satisfying.

What truly sets Cafe Plaza apart is not just the food, but the ambiance and service. The owner personally attends to guests, bringing a level of care and friendliness that enhances the dining experience. The clean, inviting space, painted in a memorable shade of blue, adds character and charm—making you feel at home from the moment you step inside.

In sum, Cafe Plaza delivers a well-rounded menu that showcases the rich flavors of Mexican cuisine while embracing local touches and American favorites. This balance, combined with heartfelt hospitality, makes it a standout spot in Columbus for both locals and visitors craving an authentic, flavorful meal in a welcoming environment.